12 disciples for every rich young ruler

In all honesty, this series on downward mobility has just about done me in. I find myself in a place of both great confidence and extreme self-doubt–especially when it comes to writing. That doesn’t sound very fun, and it really isn’t. The trouble with writing about downward mobility is that it brings up all of our baggage with money and privilege. So people respond in various ways to me, usually a variation on the theme of feeling bad about themselves. Then I, the writer (or, as is more often the case, the curator) of the series start to feel incredibly anxious. People are feeling bad about themselves! It must be because I am a terrible, horrible, snarky person. And to a degree, this is true. I am 29 years old. I am living my best life now. I am experiencing all the joys of the downward mobility journey, and also some of the hurts and isolations. So I am finding that the processing bit of this series has been a complete failure. There seems to be no way to process my downward mobility journey without coming off as self-righteous or excluding others form the conversation (which is probably why no one writes about this stuff). But it has forced me to really and truly come to my beliefs about this whole mess, what it means to give up some of what we were born with to go find Jesus in the margins.

And, I am here to tell you, I finally believe it: downward mobility is a vocation.

I never wanted to admit that before, because I didn’t want to let everyone else off the hook. For me, vocation is dripping with importance and pomp and circumstance and assurance. When people tell me that living among the poor must be my vocation, I see them distancing themselves from me, turning me into something I’m not, something holy and good and uncomplicated. I hate the word vocation, for it puts me and other practitioners up on pedestals, far above ordinary time, which is a terribly prideful, lonely place to be.

But I know–not everyone can up and move into my neighborhood (we couldn’t hold you, for starters). So I started to read books about vocation, to pray about it in my own intense way as I stomped through the leaves on my way to work, my heart thrilling at the sights and sounds and faces that I now know to be closer to me than they were a year ago, my spirit soaking up the pleasure of living in a place you adore.

There it was, all around me: joy is the root of vocation. Sacrifice is there, to be sure, but the pleasure of the work you were made to do underlies everything. As I was reading books, waiting for someone to tell me exactly what my vocation was, it became pretty apparent. It is what I am already doing, what I have been drawn to since I was a small child, which I will be drawn to for the rest of my days, no matter if I choose to obey it or not.

And that’s the thing. Maybe more are called to this life but it seems unattainable, fraught with danger, impossible to pull off well. And maybe our guilt comes from not being obedient to what would turn out to be our life’s biggest joy, learning and living and working with the people at the margins. The flip side of this, of course, is that if you aren’t called, you won’t last–and could do damage in the meantime. So it has become apparent that the idea of vocation has to be a part of the conversation surrounding downward mobility.

All that to say–today, I am here to tell you to vote for me in an online contest*. I know, right? But I entered my idea for a book and got picked as one of ten finalists for a contest the Barna Group (you know, those Christian researchers). As shocking as this may be to you all, my book idea centers around the idea of downward mobility (with a healthy dose of vocation).

Here’s a bit from the essay I submitted:


D.L. Mayfield—Downward Mobility: Gentrification, Incarnation, or Something In Between?

”We’ve all been living so good we’ve moved out of Jesus’ neighborhood”- Derek Webb

The Rich Young Ruler

A little over a year ago, my husband, baby and I sold everything we had and moved to a neighborhood far from where we grew up–both in geography and socio-economic terms. While some might think this move extreme, it’s an action that is being mirrored in cities all throughout the country. I suspect that others, like myself, have realized that our realities are not the realities of the majority world–and that we might be called to do something about it.

The poor you will always have with you, Jesus said, a phrase we trot out often. But what else did he have to say about the poor? Blessed are they, he said, along with the rest of the world we tend to forget about: the hungry, the persecuted, the sick.

In our current social climate, perhaps no story brings up such divided feelings like the story of the Rich Young Ruler; the story of a young man, eager to follow Jesus, who had all the right doctrines but who couldn’t obey when Jesus told him to sell everything he had and give it to the poor.

For many of us, this story makes our stomachs sink like a stone. Because we are rich young men and women ourselves, people of plenty in an age of hunger. Our fears about our own wealth and privilege color how we read this story. Are all of us called to do what the rich young ruler could not? As testified by the rest of the New Testament, the answer is no.

But for some, the answer is yes.

Read the rest of the essay at the contest page. And vote for the book you would most like to read!


*Contests are weird. My life is so weird. It is also pretty amazing.





Tagged , , , ,

10 thoughts on “12 disciples for every rich young ruler

  1. O says:

    Please keep writing and hosting other writers! Perhaps the voices of those of us who are deeply encouraged by what we read here are softer or fewer than those who leave feeling badly, but I want you to know that I value so greatly the thoughts I read here. No, I don’t often leave feeling good about the way I currently live my life, but I feel encouraged that there is more and that I can be brave and answer God’s call on my life. And, importantly, I always leave feeling encouraged that God loves me even as I resist His call. As someone who is a step behind you on this journey, I can’t tell you how grateful I am to read the thoughts of those who go before me, who are wrestling with the same things I am but a step further along the way. Thank you.

  2. Dan McDonald says:

    Thanks and understanding the distinction between duty and calling, the first universal and the second more singular and personal – is an important thing in keeping a sane Christian life sort of free from being judgmental. Even if at first you resisted it your blog shows a definite understanding of it in a way that helps those like me who could define it better than live it.

  3. Jill Rector says:

    Hi Danielle – I don’t often reply, but your series does make me think. Certainly there have been some of the pieces that more clearly redound with me than others. I like you current theory if vocation – it does seem like a life calling that not all are called to. Jesus loves the poor and there are also examples of people with riches in the bible as well, hopefully using those riches for the good of the believers.

    I do think that there are times when you speak truth that it will make other people uncomfortable. That’s okay. I do think if you as a prophet crying out in the wilderness. Hopefully for those whom the message is for, even if it makes them angry, anxious, or guilty, they are able to hear it.

    I appreciate hearing about your process. I probably feel like I know you much better than you fee like you know me from reading your writing. I appreciate the vulnerability. I appreciate your willingness to listen to Jesus’ calling on your life and family.

    Please keep writing and processing. I love it. Also, please include sometime in the future a piece on the “why” behind buying clothing second hand. I feel like there’s probably good information on that – just not a topic I think if researching in my spare time.

    Okay – there’s the end. Please forgive grammar and autocorrect!

    Blessings on you and the fam. – Jill


  4. liv says:

    hi there,
    i found your blog thru fpfg and have enjoyed your series for all the points of view.
    i really believe that we are all called to living in a distinctly personal way. for instance, my mom still really values church & christianity the way it has been for the past few generations (for example Billy Graham) but i can tell “there is a new thing God is doing” in my generation. in fact He is always doing a new thing in each new moment. so there are churches still for the previous generations and the old way of doing things but yet there are new movements to join as well.
    i think its the same thing with downward mobility. i grew up in an unstable family life including several divorces/marriages, poverty, alcoholsim, constant tension and other things – i never felt safe. over the past 15 years since i’ve been able to make my own choices i have crafted a life of stability, comfort and surrounded by beauty. it has taken that long to shelter myself and heal up many of my broken places. now i can easily imagine a life of simplicity and living with less (and continually move in that direction) and desperately crave connection & service to those with less. but one thing i just cant imagine giving up is the feeling of relative safety i have finally secured. i guess everyone has somewhere they must draw the line. reading the various posts made this a clear place to do that for my life. not that i am saying it is wrong for anyone else to live in less safe areas – truly we must be guided by our hearts.
    thank you for the very thoughtful series. i have enjoyed and certainly left thinking about what i read.

  5. Jim Fisher says:

    Your voice is needed! We are here to listen for it and allow it to change our hearts. For when we do sell our possessions, convert them into cash and hold them loosely, the Spirit can work much easier with coins falling between our fingers than with jewels, cars, cabins, boats, and big houses clenched in our fists.

  6. Jim Fisher says:

    In Barbara Brown Taylor’s “An Altar in the World: A Geography of Faith” there is a chapter on Vocation. I am going back to re-read it. Thank you for leading me back into her grace-filled wisdom.

  7. ELH says:

    Great essay. Thanks for your thoughts. If I’m remembering correctly, you suggested that those who are following a life of downward mobility may be either: 1) following Jesus’ words or 2) doing it out of guilt. I think there are so many other possibilities. Adventure. Pride. Praise from others (some people rather enjoy being on that pedestal to which you referred). Rich, cross-cultural experiences. I think we are all bundles of complicated motives – some pure and some not so pure.

    • so true. the disciples are a good picture of that, eh? james and john asking to sit at his left and his right (thinking they would rule in power). . . when that ended up being the cross.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: